Gay Nineties Pizza: A Pleasanton Icon's Delicious History and Modern-Day Delights

Step into a slice of Pleasanton history and discover a culinary cornerstone that has been delighting locals and visitors alike for decades. Gay Nineties Pizza isn't just a place to grab a pie; it's a vibrant testament to the town's evolution, housed within a building that whispers tales of Wells Fargo banks, bustling traveler accommodations, and even a touch of the clandestine. This iconic eatery has masterfully blended its rich past with a consistently superb present, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic, award-winning pizza in the Tri-Valley area.

From Bank Vaults to Pizza Ovens: A Remarkable Transformation

The story behind Gay Nineties Pizza is as captivating as its sourdough crust. The very structure that houses this beloved pizzeria dates back to a time when it served as a Wells Fargo Bank. Imagine the hustle and bustle of financiers and travelers in the late 19th century, with the lower floors dedicated to banking and the upper levels offering ten rooms for weary adventurers. Fast forward to the 1920s, and these same rooms reportedly transitioned into a different kind of establishment, adding another layer of intrigue to the building's already fascinating narrative.

It was within these walls, with a vision to transcend its more risqué past, that a culinary journey began. Initially, simple, hearty meals like beans with chili, served over spaghetti, graced the weekend menus. However, as demand grew and the kitchen's capacity was tested, a clever solution emerged: local pizza makers were enlisted to help lighten the load. This collaboration proved so successful that by 1968, a dedicated pizza oven was acquired, signaling a pivotal shift. The focus moved from relying on pre-made ingredients to crafting authentic, in-house pizzas. This strategic move marked the birth of Gay '90s Pizza, not only a new culinary venture but also the very first pizza parlor in Pleasanton and the broader Tri-Valley region. It was an instant hit, laying the foundation for the enduring legacy we see today.

A Culinary Experience Worth Savoring

Having been a resident of the Tri-Valley for 15 years, I can attest that Gay Nineties Pizza remains a personal favorite, a place I return to time and time again. Why? It's a captivating blend of history, a consistently lively atmosphere, and, of course, that irresistible pizza. The moment you step inside, you're enveloped in a unique culture that's both welcoming and steeped in nostalgia. But let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza.

My family and I recently had the pleasure of indulging in their offerings, and it was a meal that perfectly encapsulated the Gay Nineties experience. We started with their salads, a generous affair that offered a choice of dressing and came with either French or garlic bread. What truly impressed was how loaded the salad was; think cold cuts like turkey and ham scattered throughout, making it a substantial appetizer in itself. For our party of four, it was more than enough, with plenty of deliciousness left over.

The Main Event: Crafting Pizza Perfection

Then came the eagerly anticipated main event: pizzas crafted to our exact specifications. We opted for two 'create your own' masterpieces. The first was a classic combination of savory sausage and briny olives, while the second featured the robust flavors of sausage, sweet bell peppers, and sharp onions. The crust was a revelation - fluffy, yet possessing a delightful chew, and it held up beautifully to the generous, fresh toppings. Each bite was a testament to the quality ingredients and the care that goes into their preparation.

While the pizza was undoubtedly delicious, and the overall experience highly enjoyable, my only minor critique would be regarding the sauce. It leaned a bit one-dimensional, and I found myself wishing for a more complex blend of herbs and spices to truly elevate it. However, this was a small point in an otherwise stellar meal. We enjoyed our pizzas so much that leftovers were a welcome treat for the days that followed.

More Than Just Pizza: The Atmosphere and Service

What truly elevates a meal at Gay Nineties Pizza beyond just the food is the unparalleled atmosphere and the people who bring it to life. Our waitress was an absolute gem - friendly, attentive, and a treasure trove of information about the building's storied past. She shared anecdotes that added a rich layer of context to our dining experience, making us feel truly connected to the establishment.

Adding to the charm was a whimsical sign displayed near the kitchen, declaring 'automatic buffet.' It brought a smile to our faces and perfectly encapsulated the restaurant's playful, approachable spirit. It's these thoughtful touches, combined with the friendly staff and the sheer quality of the food, that make Gay Nineties Pizza a place people return to again and again.

Why Locals Keep Coming Back

It's no surprise that Gay Nineties Pizza is a local favorite, a go-to spot for many in Pleasanton. Patrons frequently rave about the "best pizza ever" and consider it an essential stop when visiting town. The restaurant is consistently praised for its:

Retro, Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The nicely decorated, old building exudes a cool, vintage vibe that appeals to all ages.
Homemade Pizza Excellence: From hand-pounded, slow-aged sourdough crusts to expertly crafted sauces and fresh, flavorful toppings, every pizza is a labor of love.
Award-Winning Quality: Their commitment to excellence has earned them accolades, solidifying their reputation as a top-tier pizzeria.
Generous Portions: You definitely get your money's worth, with ample toppings and satisfyingly large pizzas.
Friendly and Stellar Service: The staff consistently goes above and beyond to ensure a positive dining experience.
Convenient Location and Parking: Situated in downtown Pleasanton with adjacent shared parking, it's easily accessible.

Even those who initially perceive the pricing as slightly on the higher side quickly find it justified once they taste the quality and enjoy the overall experience. The selection is vast, ranging from gourmet creations to beloved classics, ensuring there's something to satisfy every craving. It's this consistency in delivering delicious food and a memorable atmosphere that makes Gay Nineties Pizza a true Pleasanton institution.

A Brew to Complement Your Slice

For those who appreciate a perfectly paired beverage with their pizza, Gay Nineties Pizza also caters to craft beer enthusiasts. They proudly feature Lagunitas brews, offering a fantastic opportunity to enjoy a cold, refreshing beer alongside your favorite pizza. It's the ideal way to complete a relaxed and flavorful meal.

Ordering Made Easy

Whether you're dining in or prefer to enjoy your pizza at home, Gay Nineties Pizza offers convenient delivery and takeout options. You can order online and even track your order live, ensuring a seamless experience from selection to satisfaction. With various pizza sizes and topping combinations available, including dinner specials like 12", 14", and 16" cheese pizzas with three toppings, there's a perfect option for every appetite and occasion.

Gay Nineties Pizza Co. continues to be a shining example of how a business can honor its history while embracing modern culinary standards. It's a place where delicious food, a captivating atmosphere, and friendly service converge, creating an unforgettable dining experience. So, the next time you're in Pleasanton, make sure to carve out time to savor a slice of history and flavor at this enduring local favorite.